By Nick

Every time someone finishes a puzzle on this site, we note how long it took, whether they asked for help and, since November, the order they placed their pieces in. No names, just the solve. That adds up to about 125,000 finished puzzles: 91,000 Star Battle boards since late November 2025 and 35,000 Queens boards since July 2026.

We went through all of it to answer the questions people actually ask. How long should a Star Battle take? Is Queens really that much easier? Does practice make you faster, or do you just get used to it? Here's what the numbers say, and most of the charts below are yours to play with.

How long a Star Battle takes, by level

The typical (median) 9×9 Star Battle takes about a minute on Easy, under two minutes on Medium, and three on Hard and Expert. Most solvers finish in that range, but the slowest tenth take three to five times longer: a quarter of an hour on Expert isn't unusual.

The chart below shows every finished solve at one level, from the quickest on the left to the slowest on the right. Drag across it, or use the slider, to set your own time. The coloured bars are the solves you beat.

Where does your time land?

Easy1.0 min
Medium1.8 min
Hard3.0 min
Expert3.2 min
78,000 finished 9×9 Star Battle boards and 34,700 Queens boards. The axis grows by multiples, so a slow solve doesn't squash the rest.
MinutesFastest
25%
TypicalSlowest
25%
Slowest
10%
Easy 9×90.61.01.62.7
Medium 9×91.11.83.15.4
Hard 9×91.73.05.610.0
Expert 9×91.83.26.513.4
Hard 10×102.64.47.712.7
Expert 10×102.64.48.615.8

Times in minutes. The fastest quarter finish within the first time; the slowest quarter and slowest tenth take longer than theirs.

So if your Medium took four minutes, you're slower than most people, but faster than plenty. And if Expert took you twenty minutes, you're in good company: one in ten solvers needs at least thirteen minutes.

Expert and Hard look almost the same at the median, and that hides the real gap. Expert is where people give up. Of the boards people start, 96% of Easy and 94% of Medium get finished. Hard drops to 83%. Expert drops to 67%: one in three Expert boards is abandoned.

Boards finished, of those started

Easy96%
Medium94%
Hard83%
Expert67%
53,700 Star Battle and 20,900 Queens boards started since late September 2026.

The hardest star is the first one

Since November we record the order of every move, so we can see where a solve stalls. Here is one real solve of the September 23 Expert board, finished with no hints. Press play and watch the clock. The player put down two crosses in the first 16 seconds, then placed nothing at all for 55 seconds. The first star landed at 1:12, and the other 17 followed in under a minute.

One Expert solve, played back

The gold line counts the stars on the board. Drag along it to jump to any moment.

That shape is typical of hard boards. For each recorded solve we found the longest pause, the moment someone stared at the board the longest, and counted how many stars were already down. On Easy and Medium, the long pause comes in the middle of the solve, after a handful of stars. On Expert, 65% of solvers hit their longest pause before their second star, and 35% before placing any star at all.

Stars on the board when the longest pause came

Easy13%
Medium18%
Hard39%
Expert65%
9×9 boards, 9,700 recorded solves. Tap a bar for its share.

That matches how hard boards are built. An Easy board has a region of two or three squares that gives a star away straight off. A Hard or Expert board has nothing like that, and the first star comes from combining two facts at once, usually by counting how many stars a group of rows has to hold. Once the first deduction lands, the rest of the board tends to follow. If you're stuck at the very start of an Expert board, that's normal, and our guide to the counting technique is the move you're probably missing.

The same records show how often people change their minds. On Easy, 64% of solves never take back a star. On Hard it's 31%, and on Expert just 14%. Expert solvers take a star back four times in a typical solve. Since November 9, when hints arrived, 81% of Expert solves used Check or a hint at least once, against 13% on Easy.

Practice really does make you faster

Players who stick around get much quicker. A player's first 9×9 Medium takes a typical 2.9 minutes. By their eleventh to twentieth, it's 2.0 minutes. Players past 100 Medium boards finish in 1.2 minutes, less than half the time of a first try.

Typical Medium 9×9 time, by how many Mediums you've solved

1st2.9 min
2nd–3rd2.6 min
4th–5th2.4 min
6th–10th2.2 min
11th–20th2.0 min
21st–50th1.7 min
51st–100th1.5 min
100+1.2 min
25,000 Medium solves, grouped by each player's count. Move along the line for each value.

Part of that is who keeps playing: people who are already quick are more likely to reach 100 boards. So we also followed the same 237 players from their first Medium to their twentieth; switch the chart to see them. Their typical time fell from 2.9 minutes to 1.9, a third faster in twenty boards. The line wobbles, because one board can be harder than the next, but it keeps going down. The speed-up is real, and it comes from seeing the same patterns again and again, not from rushing.

Queens is about four times quicker

Queens, the one-per-row, one-per-region puzzle LinkedIn made famous, places one queen per row instead of two stars. That one change makes it far quicker. The typical Queens board takes 14 seconds on Easy, 27 on Medium and 36 on Hard. Even the slowest tenth of Hard boards take only two minutes.

Typical solve time: Queens vs Star Battle 9×9

Queens easy14 s
Queens medium27 s
Queens hard36 s
Stars easy1.0 min
Stars medium1.8 min
Stars hard3.0 min
34,700 Queens solves and 71,000 Star Battle solves. The number under each pair is how many times longer Star Battle takes.

Almost nobody gives up on Queens: 97% to 99% of started boards get finished at every level (switch the finish chart above to Queens to see it), and only about one Hard solve in ten uses a hint. If LinkedIn's daily Queens is over in under a minute for you, Star Battle is the step up. It's the same idea with two of everything, and our Queens guide shows how the techniques carry over.

Phones are slower, but only on hard boards

On Easy, phone and desktop solvers are within about ten seconds of each other. The gap opens as the boards get harder: a typical Hard 9×9 Star Battle takes 2.5 minutes on a desktop and 3.5 on a phone, about 40% longer. Expert boards are finished less often on phones too: 62%, against 72% on a desktop.

Typical solve time, phone vs desktop

Hard, desktop2.5 min
Hard, phone3.5 min
9×9 Star Battle and all Queens solves where we know the device.

It isn't the thinking; it's the marking. Hard boards need lots of × marks, and tapping small squares is slower than clicking them. Queens, which needs far fewer marks, shows almost no gap: 38 seconds on a phone against 33 on a desktop for a Hard board.

Monday is puzzle day

You might expect puzzles to be a weekend hobby. It's the opposite. Monday is the busiest day for both games, and Saturday is the quietest. Switch the chart to hours and you'll see Star Battle solves peak between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m. US Central time and dip after work.

Share of the week's solves

Monday16.8%
Tuesday15.1%
Wednesday14.9%
Thursday15.3%
Friday13.6%
Saturday11.5%
Sunday12.8%
All 91,000 Star Battle and 35,000 Queens solves, US Central time.

A daily logic puzzle looks like a weekday habit: a few minutes with a coffee or between meetings, the same slot word games have held for years.

Is our difficulty rating right?

Every board we publish is scored by our solver before it goes live, based on which techniques it needs. The real times say the score works: within each level, boards our solver rates harder do take people longer. Each dot below is one 9×9 board; tap one to see its score and its typical time.

Solver score vs real solve time, one dot per board

Easy0.58
Medium0.49
Hard0.65
Expert0.67
Boards solved at least 15 times. Rank correlation runs from 0 (no link) to 1 (harder score, always slower).

The link is strongest on Expert (a rank correlation of 0.67) and Hard (0.65), and weakest on Medium (0.49), so a few Medium boards play harder than their label. That's what we're tuning next.

How we counted

These are finished puzzles on tryhardpuzzles.com, from members and guests, with no personal details. We dropped solves under 5 seconds or over 3 hours (mostly tabs left open). "Typical" means the median, so a handful of very slow solves can't drag it around. Star Battle times are for 9×9 boards unless we say otherwise. Finish rates count each player and board once, from late September 2026, when we started recording starts. Move-by-move records began in November 2026, so the pause and take-back figures cover about 10,600 Star Battle solves. Hint figures start on November 9, 2026. Numbers were pulled on November 16, 2026.

Want to see where your own time lands? Play today's Star Battle or today's Queens, or keep going with unlimited boards.